Petonito's Pastry and Cupcake Shoppe

Baking People Happy Since 1954

Petonito’s Pastry Shop was founded in 1954 by Mr. Salvatore Petonito. Sal and his wife Dolores ran the Pastry Shop for many years in East Haven. Sal took pride in everything that he baked and through his hard work and dedication has created an iconic landmark in the East Haven Community. His son Mark worked side by side his father for many, many years baking the delicious pastry, cookies and cakes that everyone has come to love, perfecting their recipes to make it the best place around to buy all of the Italian Classic Desserts.


Our delicious cupcakes come in two sizes, regular and jumbo. Both sizes can be filled with numerous fruits, mousses or a variety of other fillings.

Wedding Cakes

Our Shoppe offers a wide variety of styles and flavors to make your Wedding Day and Cake a memorable one!


At Petonito’s we can make you a cake for any occasion. Whether it be a birthday, anniversary, wedding, holiday or just because!


We make pounds and pounds of delicious cookies each week. Everyone adores our most popular chocolate dip and jelly filled cookies as well as our classic pignolia cookies, our cookies stuffed with fig, our shortbread cookies and our Italian Rainbow cookies.


Petonito’s Pastry and Cupcake Shoppe makes a mouth-watering assortment of the classic Italian Pastry that everyone loves.


Petonito’s Pastry & Cupcake Shoppe carries Gelato Giuliana in 19 delicious flavors.

Come on In!

Closed Monday

Tuesday – Friday

8:30 – 5:00


8:30 – 5:00


8:30 – 1:00



(203) 469-1817


190 Main St, East Haven, CT 06512